Un-Recommendations

shazam! wrote:

Tim Radd wrote:

True Believer wrote:

I can't believe we don't have a thread for this, yet. Or perhaps we do and I'm gonna look really stupid soon. Anyway, this is a thread for shitty books that you advise people to stay away from.

Batman: The Widening Gyre.

I like Kevin Smith's movies. Chasing Amy is one of my favs. This man has absolutely no business writing Batman. At all.

I'ma go ahead and say he should not write comics at all.
Nothing he has written, I have liked enough for me to have any faith in him and his comic book writing career.

You didnt like Daredevil or Green Arrow?

No, he did not.

He foolish.

True Believer wrote:

shazam! wrote:

Tim Radd wrote:

True Believer wrote:

I can't believe we don't have a thread for this, yet. Or perhaps we do and I'm gonna look really stupid soon. Anyway, this is a thread for shitty books that you advise people to stay away from.

Batman: The Widening Gyre.

I like Kevin Smith's movies. Chasing Amy is one of my favs. This man has absolutely no business writing Batman. At all.

I'ma go ahead and say he should not write comics at all.
Nothing he has written, I have liked enough for me to have any faith in him and his comic book writing career.

You didnt like Daredevil or Green Arrow?

No, he did not.

He foolish.

^this^

I said not enough for me to have faith in his comic book writing career. That doesn't mean I didn't like any of his other stuff...just didn't like a lot...or all that much.

Green Arrow and Daredevil were alright...actually not so much daredevil, IMO. Green Arrow was alright.

Tim Radd wrote:

I said not enough for me to have faith in his comic book writing career. That doesn't mean I didn't like any of his other stuff...just didn't like a lot...or all that much.

Green Arrow and Daredevil were alright...actually not so much daredevil, IMO. Green Arrow was alright.

All I know is I didn't like Daredevil or Green Arrow before I read Kevin's run on the series but I did after. I'd say the guys who came after did a better job on the series but he gave them a good starting point.

Thomas wrote:

Tim Radd wrote:

I said not enough for me to have faith in his comic book writing career. That doesn't mean I didn't like any of his other stuff...just didn't like a lot...or all that much.

Green Arrow and Daredevil were alright...actually not so much daredevil, IMO. Green Arrow was alright.

All I know is I didn't like Daredevil or Green Arrow before I read Kevin's run on the series but I did after. I'd say the guys who came after did a better job on the series but he gave them a good starting point.

I liked the characters but neither of their books, until Kevin Smith.

I didn't like Kevin Smith's Daredevil. I never read his Green Arrow.

Liquid Sword wrote:

I didn't like Kevin Smith's Daredevil. I never read his Green Arrow.

i'd say green arrow's the better of the 2 but neither were bad. i mean not fuckin stellar but they were worth reading one or twice.

JLA vs Predator GAY AS FUCK

Galacta: Daughter of Galactus.



Pure horrible from the art to the writing to the concept.

Spoiler:

GreatWhiteNinja wrote:

Galacta: Daughter of Galactus.



Pure horrible from the art to the writing to the concept.

Spoiler:

This book sounds horrible except for what's in the spoiler.

Mr.Wholesome wrote:

Thomas wrote:

Tim Radd wrote:

I said not enough for me to have faith in his comic book writing career. That doesn't mean I didn't like any of his other stuff...just didn't like a lot...or all that much.

Green Arrow and Daredevil were alright...actually not so much daredevil, IMO. Green Arrow was alright.

All I know is I didn't like Daredevil or Green Arrow before I read Kevin's run on the series but I did after. I'd say the guys who came after did a better job on the series but he gave them a good starting point.

I liked the characters but neither of their books, until Kevin Smith.

Kevin Smith's DD is alright.


You NEEEEEEED to read Frank Miller's Daredevil!!!!!!!!!!!!

Ultimates 3.

Did Loeb read any ultimate books before he wrote it?
At all?

Storywise it is by far one of the worst comics that I have ever read. Ever.

shazam! wrote:

Ultimates 3.

Did Loeb read any ultimate books before he wrote it?
At all?

Storywise it is by far one of the worst comics that I have ever read. Ever.

idk what surprises me most, u just figga'd out how shitty things loeb books are (some yellow in there somewhere im fucked up..)

shazam! wrote:

Ultimates 3.

Did Loeb read any ultimate books before he wrote it?
At all?

Storywise it is by far one of the worst comics that I have ever read. Ever.

idk what surprises me most, u just figga'd out how shitty things loeb books are (some yellow in there somewhere im fucked up..)

i chose 2 edit my own post cuz im pretty fucked up im sure if im makin sense

shazam! wrote:

Ultimates 3.

Did Loeb read any ultimate books before he wrote it?
At all?

Storywise it is by far one of the worst comics that I have ever read. Ever.

Not to mention that while Joe Mad!'s art is sweet, he didn't bother to pay attention that Ultimates costumes are different than 616.

Liquid Sword wrote:

shazam! wrote:

Ultimates 3.

Did Loeb read any ultimate books before he wrote it?
At all?

Storywise it is by far one of the worst comics that I have ever read. Ever.

Not to mention that while Joe Mad!'s art is sweet, he didn't bother to pay attention that Ultimates costumes are different than 616.

Yeah.
wtf was up with ultimate Thor using a 616 looking Mjolnir?

Theres just so much wrong with ultimates 3 I don't even know where to begin.

shazam! wrote:

Liquid Sword wrote:

shazam! wrote:

Ultimates 3.

Did Loeb read any ultimate books before he wrote it?
At all?

Storywise it is by far one of the worst comics that I have ever read. Ever.

Not to mention that while Joe Mad!'s art is sweet, he didn't bother to pay attention that Ultimates costumes are different than 616.

Yeah.
wtf was up with ultimate Thor using a 616 looking Mjolnir?

Theres just so much wrong with ultimates 3 I don't even know where to begin.

its Loeb, hes the hottest fuck up on the marvel side ive scene

NoLuv4Hoes wrote:

shazam! wrote:

Liquid Sword wrote:

shazam! wrote:

Ultimates 3.

Did Loeb read any ultimate books before he wrote it?
At all?

Storywise it is by far one of the worst comics that I have ever read. Ever.

Not to mention that while Joe Mad!'s art is sweet, he didn't bother to pay attention that Ultimates costumes are different than 616.

Yeah.
wtf was up with ultimate Thor using a 616 looking Mjolnir?

Theres just so much wrong with ultimates 3 I don't even know where to begin.

its Loeb, hes the hottest fuck up on the marvel side ive scene

It's too bad really, he's written so much awesome stuff.

shazam! wrote:

NoLuv4Hoes wrote:

shazam! wrote:

Liquid Sword wrote:

shazam! wrote:

Ultimates 3.

Did Loeb read any ultimate books before he wrote it?
At all?

Storywise it is by far one of the worst comics that I have ever read. Ever.

Not to mention that while Joe Mad!'s art is sweet, he didn't bother to pay attention that Ultimates costumes are different than 616.

Yeah.
wtf was up with ultimate Thor using a 616 looking Mjolnir?

Theres just so much wrong with ultimates 3 I don't even know where to begin.

its Loeb, hes the hottest fuck up on the marvel side ive scene

It's too bad really, he's written so much awesome stuff.

He has.....for DC, but he's yet to shine in Marvel. It's a shame I think his son's death has kinda affected his writing negatively..shame.

TJ wrote:

shazam! wrote:

NoLuv4Hoes wrote:

shazam! wrote:

Liquid Sword wrote:

shazam! wrote:

Ultimates 3.

Did Loeb read any ultimate books before he wrote it?
At all?

Storywise it is by far one of the worst comics that I have ever read. Ever.

Not to mention that while Joe Mad!'s art is sweet, he didn't bother to pay attention that Ultimates costumes are different than 616.

Yeah.
wtf was up with ultimate Thor using a 616 looking Mjolnir?

Theres just so much wrong with ultimates 3 I don't even know where to begin.

its Loeb, hes the hottest fuck up on the marvel side ive scene

It's too bad really, he's written so much awesome stuff.

He has.....for DC, but he's yet to shine in Marvel. It's a shame I think his son's death has kinda affected his writing negatively..shame.

he does well with the colored stuff (that sounds a little racist huh) but his main projects suck more than Carlito's mom on a Thursday

shazam! wrote:

Liquid Sword wrote:

shazam! wrote:

Ultimates 3.

Did Loeb read any ultimate books before he wrote it?
At all?

Storywise it is by far one of the worst comics that I have ever read. Ever.

Not to mention that while Joe Mad!'s art is sweet, he didn't bother to pay attention that Ultimates costumes are different than 616.

Yeah.
wtf was up with ultimate Thor using a 616 looking Mjolnir?

Theres just so much wrong with ultimates 3 I don't even know where to begin.

Towards the end of the arc, they showed that Thor had a bunch of different versions of Mjolnir. The 616 looking hammer was sitting right next to the Ultimate one.

Leachcraft wrote:

shazam! wrote:

Liquid Sword wrote:

shazam! wrote:

Ultimates 3.

Did Loeb read any ultimate books before he wrote it?
At all?

Storywise it is by far one of the worst comics that I have ever read. Ever.

Not to mention that while Joe Mad!'s art is sweet, he didn't bother to pay attention that Ultimates costumes are different than 616.

Yeah.
wtf was up with ultimate Thor using a 616 looking Mjolnir?

Theres just so much wrong with ultimates 3 I don't even know where to begin.

Towards the end of the arc, they showed that Thor had a bunch of different versions of Mjolnir. The 616 looking hammer was sitting right next to the Ultimate one.

You know what's never made sense is that asgardians don't make more Uru weapons for their warriors. They made a hammer for Beta Ray Bill and a mace for Eric Masterson but they can't make some cool weapons for the Warriors Three, Balder, Heimdall, or Sif?

Leachcraft wrote:

shazam! wrote:

Liquid Sword wrote:

shazam! wrote:

Ultimates 3.

Did Loeb read any ultimate books before he wrote it?
At all?

Storywise it is by far one of the worst comics that I have ever read. Ever.

Not to mention that while Joe Mad!'s art is sweet, he didn't bother to pay attention that Ultimates costumes are different than 616.

Yeah.
wtf was up with ultimate Thor using a 616 looking Mjolnir?

Theres just so much wrong with ultimates 3 I don't even know where to begin.

Towards the end of the arc, they showed that Thor had a bunch of different versions of Mjolnir. The 616 looking hammer was sitting right next to the Ultimate one.

Oh yeah. That seemed like it was thrown in there to explain why Joe Mad! was drawing the wrong hammer the whole time.

Thomas wrote:

Leachcraft wrote:

shazam! wrote:

Liquid Sword wrote:

shazam! wrote:

Ultimates 3.

Did Loeb read any ultimate books before he wrote it?
At all?

Storywise it is by far one of the worst comics that I have ever read. Ever.

Not to mention that while Joe Mad!'s art is sweet, he didn't bother to pay attention that Ultimates costumes are different than 616.

Yeah.
wtf was up with ultimate Thor using a 616 looking Mjolnir?

Theres just so much wrong with ultimates 3 I don't even know where to begin.

Towards the end of the arc, they showed that Thor had a bunch of different versions of Mjolnir. The 616 looking hammer was sitting right next to the Ultimate one.

You know what's never made sense is that asgardians don't make more Uru weapons for their warriors. They made a hammer for Beta Ray Bill and a mace for Eric Masterson but they can't make some cool weapons for the Warriors Three, Balder, Heimdall, or Sif?

....actually thats a really good point